Cancel
Save avatar

Change avatar costs 20 points

Noissar
1475 points
Level 72
407 Comment(s)
421 Upvote(s)
Noissar Noissar - 1753477646
The problem is the simplification: Loading will say something in the spirit of: That person is such a bad driver, they even have history of being in a car accident. That is what they will say, but in reality (of this fake example) the driver will be below average or average driver most days and will have a bad run of things every few months and the accident they were in was because someone else ran a Red Light or a Stop Sign and crashed into the side of their vehicle when they had 'right of way'.

This is what I feel is the nuance that is being lost, mostly my own fault on this one, I admit once again. My 'Problem' is that between the start and the end of they story is where these "opinion" they lie to you.

The supporting points are proof in themselves. He is not a devil but not an angel either, he is abusive but also kind, not the strongest but not the weakest either, not eccentric but not normal either.
does Devilish and Angelic like actions = being bland/indecisive?
abusive but also kind = just regular people things?
not the Strongest but not the weakest = average at everything?
not eccentric but not normal = ???; what does this even mean - does an odd things from time to time?

Follows that up with: "Basically you can replace the protagonist with a cardboard cutout and no one will notice the difference"

It is just... I do no know. To me personally? These are acting like describing the Short-Tall man that is a 2 handed, 2 legged, average person with no presence. It mixes things that only hold up on the face of it; there is a massive difference between Angel and Demon behaviour, you can have both in the same person. You can not how ever have a Short-Tall person{without defining outside factors [like short to an adult, tall to a child] , not explaining those factors before hand... I would call that dishonest; especcially if it was integral to the point}
2
2
Noissar Niafloa - 1753477547
You were absolutely right in many ways; I said a lot , so that I could basically say nothing.

What I should have said is something along the lines of:
Loadings points have a point of contradicting themselves (here and elsewhere), and from reading other reviews from Loading they state their "opinions" as if they are facts that should justify the opinions themselves. The issues is these opinion at best are misunderstood or worse just outright not accurate and they a habit of basing these opinion/facts on things that appear to be a twisted reality or outright misunderstood.

To be negative about it: They have successfully lied and tricked you. The Bloat explains what I mean in more detail.

Bloat is in a follow-up comment.
1
0
Loading gives their "opinion" but state it as if it were facts and if they are to be taken as facts then they are provably wrong - that is the problem.

Sure the reply was childish, I will accept that wholeheartedly. Just tell me in what way it was inaccurate? Maybe I can do better, if someone actually did...that would be something. The problem here is Loading likes to go around and pretend that their opinion is expressed as an opinion; in multiple places (at least 2), leading many people astray.

If you recognize their handle and generally agree with their tastes, that is awesome for you. It is just a lack of empathy to think everyone thinks the same way. I am not even saying the story great read or a bad read for you - just do not allow others to make things up and/or give their negative slanted (false) information to try and ruin what others may like.

Niafloa said:
Thanks for the review, guys like you help save time for people who doesn't want to invest their time reading something they might not like. Just ignore the other dude xD

The key here is: "might not like"; it is being done dirty when Loading violates that trust by giving false/inaccurate information.

But after looking at it again I was being an emotional Twat at the time, that was my bad. Though I will stand behind saying Loading is untrustworthy; their negative points do not match reality at least in how they overly simplify the things they say.

Even if we agree on the start and ending, a STORY is about how you get there; that is (for me at the very least) the whole point of reading something. So to be dishonest about that...
3
1
Noissar - 1752479201
MC feels like he has just become a fool, it is like he is just being pushed along with 1/100 on the self agency scale. It is really got me at a point where I just feel like everything should match up and make sense. It just does not, it is like one of the face pictures where the eyes and mouth are in the wrong spots but looks right till you notice the head itself is upside-down.

Maybe it would have been better to say: MC feels like he is becoming more and more of an imposter that does not fit in this story...
1
0
Noissar Cat - 1752478404
I can agree whole heartedly with that!

It has been so long but I feel like the 'Severed Hand' thing was actually legit. So it was truly written in with intent if so...

But sadly this feels like it is just constantly missing the mark and the vibe has been killed, cause the whole hand thing should be brilliant it has the hallmarks of a great setup. Ahhh it just hit me; the vibe has become the same as when someone tries to tell a joke but botches the Punch-Line massively, so it should have been funny but was smothered in the cradle with roadkill from a couple cities away.
1
0
Noissar - 1752474660
I am nearly certain those 2 "knights" committed Lese Majeste, twice over possibly. They effectively insulted a representative of a Foreign King, and denounced the Kings official documents as forgeries. On the other side they threaten the wellbeing of their own Royalty attempting to drive away an individual that brought requested medical ingredients... If this was not a lighthearted story, they would not even have gotten the dignity of being put in the dirt.
3
0
Noissar Bruce - 1751883253
I was mildly let down at the revenge.
It missed that poetic mark by not loading her up with the poison to quote 'Honor' her parents death.
A few needles to the eyes slash face before the heart stab would have made it more "right" in my mind. Especially after emphasizing on Fighting Dirty.
0
0
Noissar SingleBite - 1750683203
~Obligatory, could have used better language aside.

You can not logic a person into reason when they Deify their personal feelings over everything else and either reject reality or are not capable of understanding it.

I was just dropping a comment to say: good work or something like that.
It is really something to go back and forth with a... individual... that fails their own logic standard repeatedly.

This really reminded me of time where I got into it with a, individual... that was tossing out "facts" that were factually and provably wrong to slander a story they did not like and then tried to fall back on the "it's just an Opinion" copout pretending that everything they said was an actual opinion and not some kind of hate campaign of sorts.
0
0
Noissar SingleBite - 1750673762
They are aware/know about Germs, it was mentioned that they know about it as it is knowledge that was retained from the Ancient Eras. It was previously mentioned in basically 1 panel and arguable referenced in at least 2 more instances that were also easily miss able.
0
0
Noissar - 1750400843
I want to say that a Hero going Rouge like that is Dark as F---, but when Humans are taken at face value; would not be surprised it that was a 50/50 chance to go Evil/Good.
0
0
Noissar - 1750316644
They must have gotten some massive hate laden feedback, and just overcorrected like mad. We went from typical multiple chapters to sum up a boring fight that has been done several times to a couple panels with nearly no time wasted... I... am not even mad about it. Drawing out fights that are nothing more than: *Face Slapped; Neck Broke* is done in such poor taste.

Feels like they have gotten close to a sweet spot with this one, hope they maintain it!
0
0
It is a combined / coordinated attack with one instance of attacking, I get what you mean. It just depends on how frame it.

A single synchronized shot from an artillery line is still a "one shot" or "one attack" because it is a group attack that happens in 1 moment, possibly not the best example. (but the argument could be applied at scale to a shotgun, no?)

On the other end of it - likely still not the best example, does using an ability like: Double Slash or Triple Stab qualify as a 1-shot; it is one ability that has multiple actions...

There are also those that would include attacks with lethal poison/venom, as a 'one shot kill' but while I can agree with them to an extent... I feel there is a always an invisible time requirement that if it goes over 2-3 seconds it loses most if not all of the prestige that is implied with a One Shot Kill.
0
0
Noissar Mangaguy - 1749783038
They had Ear Plugs/Protection. They had to block out the song/hymn so they should not have been able to actually hear him, but honestly just sitting around waiting for the plot to happen instead of just vaporizing him instantly... it really is something...
1
0
Noissar Gluttony - 1749613805
Brain chemicals have gone bad; human tier thought - Disabled.
0
0
Noissar - 1749613045
That... has to be the greatest idiot villain thing ever... it is like a built in clean up code/function. "The entire army falls if you kill the Necromancer?", I love that weakness! let me have it!
1
0
Noissar Mr. Gram - 1749607018
The initial starting point was 2h, but even the the maths are not math-ing. lol nice catch!
0
0
Noissar Vanda - 1749604015
It was explained away with no one being able to tame a dragon.

Still makes Zero sense when the little princess's puppet was flying through levels with the half/land dragon.

It is possible they just did not really put forward how 'rare' the occupation was nor how 'impossible' it was to obtain even a low rank egg - though MC used a super rare drop from an Otherworlder's bonus system to obtain his; but they made it look like any normal to moronic person could just stumble onto one at any moment when he got it.
3
0
Noissar Vanda - 1749574374
he basically has a guide book to power(the system).

I think the real question is why are there human shaped(?) cocoons in the dragon nest... I feel like I am seeing them everywhere in this one.
1
0
Noissar G-Fischj - 1749157817
That is 100% what I thought.

Minus the Parallel Universe it fits. Idiocracy, dude gets cryogenically frozen along side a average IQ hooker for long(?) time. So best argument is he was in one from the start and not 'wakes up' in one. Needless nitpick but my point stands, for the sake of accuracy only.

Amazing movie though, terrifying in how real the premise has become....
0
0
Noissar - 1748810046
Normally I would read a chapter title then proceed to forget it before the chapter is over, but this one managed to be both genuine and sarcastic at the same time. Just when the promise was fulfilled, it was subverted at the end, All of it is marred by the weird stalker/forum thing though... making sure children are safe but doing it in a flip-flop creepy but sometimes not fashion is cringe!
0
0