Cancel
Save avatar

Change avatar costs 20 points

smithtable15
1267 points
77 Comment(s)
24 Upvote(s)
smithtable15 - 1729588150
Pretty good to start, but gets worse as it goes. Art is average at best, MC is pretty good, but a lot of plot points feel asspulled, with one arc being a complete Castlevania rip. Nothing really unique about it, as it takes from every magic fantasy manhwa cliche, and the writing isn't very strong
0
0
smithtable15 Not0seven - 1729472484
okay then just waste your time reading this crap. the point of the comment section is to express opinions. why try to fool people trying to get into it? the main character sucks and doesn't get any better in over 100 chapters. if that's not an indictment of quality, i don't know what is.
0
0
smithtable15 Adam - 1729472462
in the 125 chapters i read, he had no character growth and was a plateau of stupidity because "being dumb is funny." he is literally the kind of character who would find an OP weapon like excalibur and throw it away because "it doesn't work" ; he has zero brain cells. he is an extremely unlikable protagonist who improves completely by accident. it is not rewarding to read so many chapters when you have to put up with an awful main character.
0
0
smithtable15 - 1715205789
what a wh*re. next, she's gonna try calling him by his first name, that shameless skank
0
0
smithtable15 - 1715198542
So many of these Japanese MCs have the easiest road to romance possible and still waste away their youth with obliviousness. This is the kind of guy who could get married and have kids with this girl and still think to himself "I have no idea what she's thinking. I wonder how she feels about me." I get the whole "mob character" premise, but still. Nobody could possibly flirt more directly and obviously than the girl in this. MC in this is about as empty and insert as possible. He does not have a single thought that isn't motivated by main girl or his little brother. What's telling about this genre is that MC here is actually one of the most likable ones.
0
0
smithtable15 - 1715108564
bro the japanese are pedophiles. how is this shit legal? somehow underage drinking is censored and avoided with a ten foot pole, but a 30 year old man screwing a 15 year old is completely acceptable? the degeneracy and evil that's given the green light in japanese media is absolutely appalling.
0
0
smithtable15 - 1715108258
japan has a major pedo problem. there's no way underage girls are sexualized this much without there being a major issue with the whole culture, i'm sorry. disgusting
0
0
smithtable15 - 1713490068
this gem gets axed but copy-pasted op titty harem or revenge necromancer shit gets 150+ chapters. the koreans and japanese are allergic to quality content
1
0
smithtable15 - 1713430231
i've read a lot of stupid japanese plots but this might be the absolute worst.
0
0
smithtable15 Thyself - 1713409382
you don't understand this manga at all if you think he's going to execute people
0
0
smithtable15 - 1713306895
MC's warped logic in this early scenario always makes me laugh.
0
0
it's unfortunate that this isn't good given how many chapters there are. everything satisfying just doesn't have enough length to dig in, while garbage like Overgeared is impervious to cancellation and will have hundreds of chapters with solid art.
0
0
smithtable15 Rubble - 1704277239
novel has one girl, no harem. MC is romantically oblivious as a character trait and FC is romantically proactive. Don't think romance comes for a long while though
0
0
smithtable15 - 1704276801
It's funny, interesting, and the novel has no harem (only a single woman partner). The impossible has happened and somehow there is a good manhua. I don't know how they did it when every other manhua without exception is unreadable garbage that makes you dumber. Read this and behold a miracle
0
0
smithtable15 - 1704274893
This sucks. FL, in order to get the perfect revenge or something, doesn't do anything to blonde shithead ex for over 100 chapters. it's her goal the entire manhwa and she's depicted as a just character, but would rather have people die in ignorance of Gaspar's lies, abuse, etc. rather than reveal him. She effectively lets people die for no reason at all; bad guy has MC-level plot armor for exaggerated and ridiculous prolonged drama. It feels like the author didn't want to kill him off because they had no other ideas about where the plot could go otherwise. Just absolutely terrible and builds to nothing.
4
0
smithtable15 - 1704163054
the art in this is disgusting; MC is so unlikable it's crazy. 3/10
0
0
smithtable15 - 1704161640
This is the type of manga where the MCs will thwart an evil character's plans and then just let them go every single time, whether demon, evil character who kills people, evil character who tries to kill children and destroy the town, etc. Then that evil character will show up again and again, endangering many of the MCs' friends and acquaintances. Then, a demon will come and be like, "they don't like you and might think you're worthless, but I can help you" if you just do X horrible thing, or become possessed by a demon. This is the kind of story where the MC not killing people to maintain the status quo always causes more problems because the people he lets go always have grudges the demons exploit. Maybe this is just the way mangaka like to write stories, but I find this kind of conflict to be pretty annoying. MC is a massive mary sue who thinks taking half measures against evil rather than fully resolving the problem will somehow allow him to continue his peaceful life. The characterization of most other characters is well done, but it just isn't that enjoyable to me. 6.5/10
0
0
smithtable15 - 1703991129
i wish there was a chinese tag on this site (or else a consistently applies manhua tag) so i could filter it all out. every manhua is bad, no exceptions.
0
0